The notion of an axiom is borrowed from logic and mathematics.
An axiom is a foundational assumption that is made which relates basic concepts in the theory. An axiom is essentially a stipulation, in that it cannot be shown to follow from other assumptions. The reason why axioms are important is that (a) they clarify the very basic foundational assumptions of a field, and (b) allow one to establish the logical consequences of those assumptions.
The existence of a clearly stated, precise axiom drives theoretical discourse in another way. Once the axiom is clearly stated, it gives rise to the question of whether there are even more fundamental axioms (assumptions, stipulations) from which it could be derived.
An example from set theory is the Axiom of Extensionality: Two sets are equal if and only if they have the exact same elements. This axiom determines how sets behave by relating identity to set membership. In effect, the axioms of set theory define what it means to be a set.
Another example of an axiom from set theory is the Axiom of Pairing: For any two sets A and B, there is a set that contains A and B as elements. This axiom is particularly important for syntactic theory because it allows us to define Merge.
There is a difference between a definition and an axiom. The definition of Merge is Merge(A,B) = {A,B} (for A and B distinct syntactic objects). This is also a stipulation, but it does not count as an axiom. Rather, it is the very definition of what we mean by the operation Merge. In effect, the term Merge is a shorthand way to refer to the formation of a binary set.
A possible example of an axiom in syntactic theory is the No Tampering Condition (see Collins and Stabler 2016 for a formalized version):
No Tampering Condition
Syntactic operations do not change the syntactic objects that they operate on.
Stating this as an axiom in a formal system helps clarify foundational assumptions and also helps to develop a set of logical consequences of those assumptions. For example, one logical consequence of the No Tampering Condition is that movement does not leave traces.
Stating the NTC as an axiom also allows one to try to unpack the NTC and to investigate whether it is a consequence of other more fundamental assumptions. For example, Collins and Stabler 2016 argue that the NTC is a theorem (Theorem 8) of the system, not an axiom.
In the formalization of Collins and Stabler 2016, the only axioms are the standard axioms of set theory (e.g., the Axiom of Extensionality and the Axiom of Pairing). In addition, there is a set of definitions of the basic concepts and operations (e.g., lexical item, Merge, workspace, occurrence). From those definitions and axioms, the properties of the system are proven (such as the No Tampering Condition).
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.