Sunday, July 14, 2024
Principles of Argument Structure (Combined Excerpts)
Here are a series of four short excerpts from my forthcoming MIT Press monograph giving a taste of some of the theoretical issues that I engage with.
Principles of Argument Structure (Final Prepublication Version, April 28 2023)
Principles of Argument Structure (Excerpt 4: Collins 2005 vs Bruening 2013)
To summarize the discussion, we have the following two theories and their properties:
(5) Collins 2005a (see also Angelopoulos et. al. 2020):
a. Principles: Theta-Criterion/Argument Criterion
b. Prediction: Implicit arguments are syntactically projected.
c. Empirical support: distribution of reflexives, reciprocals, pronouns, Helke expressions and secondary predicates in the short passive in English.
(6) Bruening 2013 (see also Legate 2014 and Alexiadou et. al. 2015):
a. Principles: No Theta-Criterion/Argument Criterion, only formal semantics
b. Prediction: Implicit arguments are not syntactically projected.
c. Empirical problems: distribution of reflexives, reciprocals, pronouns, Helke expressions and secondary predicates in the short passive in English.
Book Proposal: In Search of the Roots of Human Language
In Search of the Roots of Human Language:
The Autobiography of Christopher Thad Collins
Synopsis/Back Cover:
Follow the life journey of a mild-mannered professor from modest beginnings, deep into the heart of Africa in search of the meaning of life and the secrets of human language.
Saturday, July 13, 2024
Principles of Argument Structure (Final Pre-publication Version, April 28 2023)
Dedication
This monograph is dedicated to my three great syntax teachers, Noam Chomsky, Richard Kayne and Paul Postal. Their influence can be felt on every page.
Principles of Argument Structure (Final Pre-Publication Version)
Principles of Argument Structure (Excerpt 3: Formal Semantics)
The discussion above raises the question of where formal semantics goes wrong as a theory of argument structure? The basic problem is that formal semantics (as presented in standard textbooks) is far too unrestricted to serve as theory of anything, even natural language semantics. As Chomsky notes in Collins 2021:
(35) “Work in formal semantics has been some of the most exciting parts of the field in recent years, but it hasn’t been treated with the kind of critical analysis that other parts of syntax (including generative phonology) have been within generative grammar since its origins. Questions about explanatory power, simplicity, learnability, generality, evolvability, and so. More as a descriptive technology. That raises questions.”
.jpg)
.jpg)